Question 1

Credit Card Tipping

Accepted Answer

is the most common modern variation, executed by writing a specific amount on a merchant receipt or selecting a percentage on a digital Point-of-Sale (POS) terminal. While convenient for the consumer, credit card tips introduce friction for the worker. Employers must pay merchant processing fees (typically 2.5% to 3.5%) to credit card companies. Under federal law, employers are permitted to deduct the exact percentage of the processing fee from the worker's tip. If a customer leaves a $20 tip on a Visa card with a 3% fee, the employer legally deducts $0.60, and the server receives $19.40. Furthermore, credit card tips are automatically reported to the IRS and are usually withheld until the bi-weekly paycheck is issued, denying the worker immediate access to their earnings.

Question 2

Digital Screen Tipping

Accepted Answer

(often via iPad or Square terminals) has introduced the phenomenon of "tip creep" into non-traditional tipping environments like bakeries, retail stores, and fast-casual counters. These systems utilize psychological anchoring, presenting the customer with pre-calculated, often inflated options (e.g., 18%, 20%, 25%) while standing directly in front of the cashier. Envelope Tipping is a specialized variation used almost exclusively in the lodging and travel industry, where cash is placed inside a clearly marked envelope left in a hotel room for housekeeping staff, ensuring the money is recognized as a tip and not simply misplaced guest property.

Question 3

Scenario 1: The High-End Haircut.

Accepted Answer

A consumer visits a salon for a cut, color, and blowout. The total cost of the service is $250. The stylist spent three hours on the client's hair, and an assistant washed the hair. The consumer must calculate 20% of the $250 base price, resulting in a $50 tip. If the salon allows it, the consumer should hand $40 to the primary stylist and $10 directly to the assistant who performed the wash. If tipping via credit card at the front desk, the $50 is added, and the receptionist ensures the split.

Question 4

Scenario 2: The Multi-Day Hotel Stay.

Accepted Answer

A business traveler stays at a mid-tier Marriott for four nights. The room costs $180 per night. The consumer must not wait until checkout to leave a $20 bill. Housekeeping staff rotates schedules, meaning the person who cleans the room on Tuesday may not be the person who cleans it on Friday. The consumer must leave $5 in cash, clearly marked with a note saying "Thank You Housekeeping," on the pillow or desk every single morning before leaving the room. The total tipping outlay is $20, but the daily distribution ensures the specific worker performing the labor that day is compensated.

Question 5

Scenario 3: The Heavily Discounted Meal.

Accepted Answer

Two patrons dine at a restaurant during a "Half-Price Wine and Appetizer" promotional hour. The bill arrives at $45. However, if the items had been purchased at full retail price, the bill would have been $90. The server performed the exact same amount of physical labor—carrying the same weight, walking the same steps, providing the same attention—as they would have for a full-price meal. The consumer must calculate the 20% tip based on the original $90 value. The tip must be $18, not $9. Tipping on the discounted amount severely penalizes the server for a marketing promotion designed by the restaurant's management.

Question 6

Do I need to tip on alcohol, and does the percentage change for expensive bottles of wine?

Accepted Answer

Yes, you must tip on alcohol, but the etiquette shifts slightly at the extreme high end. For standard drinks, cocktails, and moderately priced wine (under $100), apply the standard 20% to the total cost. However, if you purchase a highly expensive bottle of wine (e.g., a $500 vintage), the physical labor of opening and pouring that bottle is identical to a $40 bottle. In fine dining, it is acceptable to scale the tip back on exorbitant wine purchases, often leaving 10% to 15% specifically on the wine portion of the bill, while maintaining 20% on the food. If a dedicated sommelier guided the selection, a higher percentage is warranted to compensate for their specialized expertise.

Question 7

How do I handle tipping when paying with a gift card?

Accepted Answer

You must tip based on the total monetary value of the bill before the gift card was applied. A gift card is merely a form of currency, not a discount on the labor provided. If your meal costs $100 and you use a $100 gift card, your remaining balance is $0, but the server still performed $100 worth of labor. You must leave a $20 tip, preferably in cash or by putting a credit card down solely to charge the gratuity. Never leave a $0 tip simply because the gift card covered the cost of the meal.

Question 8

Should I tip a repair person or contractor working in my home?

Accepted Answer

Generally, no. Plumbers, electricians, HVAC technicians, and general contractors are highly skilled tradespeople who set their own hourly rates or work for companies that pay them standard, non-tipped professional wages. Tipping them is not culturally expected and can sometimes be viewed as patronizing. However, if a tradesperson performs a massive favor outside the scope of their contract (e.g., an electrician fixing an extra outlet for free, or a furniture delivery crew navigating a brutally difficult flight of stairs), offering $20 to $50 in cash as a gesture of appreciation is highly polite, though never mandatory.

Question 9

What is the difference in tip etiquette between grocery delivery and restaurant food delivery?

Accepted Answer

Restaurant delivery (DoorDash, UberEats) involves a driver picking up a pre-packaged hot meal; the benchmark is 20% or a $5 minimum. Grocery delivery (Instacart, Shipt) requires vastly more labor. The worker must drive to the store, physically walk the aisles, select high-quality produce, wait in checkout lines, bag the items, and haul heavy bags to your door. Because the time and physical exertion are significantly higher, the absolute minimum tip for grocery delivery should be 15% to 20% of the total grocery bill, with an additional cash bonus if the order includes exceptionally heavy items like multiple cases of water or 40-pound bags of pet food.

Question 10

If I order at a counter but the staff brings the food to my table, what do I tip?

Accepted Answer

This hybrid model, often called "fast-casual" (e.g., Panera Bread, local cafes), does not require the full 20% dine-in gratuity because the server is not taking your order at the table, refilling your drinks, or clearing your plates continuously. However, because they are running food to the dining room and bussing tables after you leave, a 10% to 15% tip is the standard benchmark. This compensates the workers for the partial table service provided beyond a standard fast-food transaction.

Question 11

Is it ever acceptable to ask a service worker if they actually receive the credit card tip?

Accepted Answer

Yes, it is highly acceptable and often appreciated by workers, though it must be asked politely and discreetly. You can simply ask, "Do you get to keep your credit card tips, or is cash better for you?" In almost all cases, the worker will express a strong preference for cash due to immediate liquidity and the avoidance of credit card processing fees deducted by the employer. Asking this question demonstrates high cultural awareness and a genuine concern for the worker's financial well-being, marking you as a considerate and educated consumer.

Tip Etiquette Guide

Command Palette