Question 1

Scenario 1: The High-Earning Surgeon in California.

Accepted Answer

Dr. Smith lives in Los Angeles and earns $800,000 per year. She is in the highest federal tax bracket (37%), pays the 3.8% Net Investment Income Tax, and falls into California's highest state income tax bracket of 13.3%. Her total combined marginal tax rate is an incredible 54.1% (37% + 3.8% + 13.3%). Dr. Smith performs the tax-equivalent yield calculation for the 3.75% municipal bond. She calculates 1 - 0.541 = 0.459. She then divides the muni yield by this figure: 3.75% / 0.459 = 8.17%. For Dr. Smith, the 3.75% municipal bond is equivalent to a taxable bond yielding 8.17%. Since the corporate bond is only offering 5.50%, the municipal bond is the overwhelmingly superior choice. Buying the corporate bond would be a massive financial mistake for her.

Question 2

Scenario 2: The Mid-Career Teacher in Nevada.

Accepted Answer

Mr. Johnson lives in Las Vegas and earns $65,000 per year. He files his taxes as a single individual, placing him in the 22% federal marginal tax bracket. Nevada has zero state income tax, and his income is far too low to trigger the 3.8% NIIT. His total marginal tax rate is simply 22%. Mr. Johnson performs the exact same calculation on the exact same 3.75% municipal bond. He calculates 1 - 0.22 = 0.78. He divides the muni yield by this figure: 3.75% / 0.78 = 4.80%. For Mr. Johnson, the municipal bond is equivalent to a taxable bond yielding 4.80%. Since the corporate bond is offering 5.50%, the corporate bond is the clear winner for him.

Question 3

What happens to my tax-equivalent yield if tax brackets are changed by Congress?

Accepted Answer

If Congress passes legislation that raises marginal income tax rates, the value of tax-exempt municipal bonds increases immediately. Because the denominator in the formula (1 - Tax Rate) becomes smaller, the resulting tax-equivalent yield becomes higher. Conversely, if Congress lowers tax rates, the tax-equivalent yield of your municipal bonds will decrease, making them less competitive against taxable corporate bonds. This is why municipal bond prices often fluctuate based on political election results and anticipated tax policy changes.

Question 4

Do I need to calculate tax-equivalent yield if I am buying bonds inside my IRA or 401(k)?

Accepted Answer

No, you should almost never buy municipal bonds inside a tax-advantaged account like a Traditional IRA, Roth IRA, or 401(k). These accounts already protect your investments from annual taxes. Because you are not paying taxes on the interest generated inside the account, the tax rate variable is effectively zero. Therefore, you simply compare the absolute, stated yields. A 6% corporate bond will always beat a 4% municipal bond inside an IRA. Municipal bonds are specifically designed for standard, taxable brokerage accounts.

Question 5

Why is my accountant telling me my municipal bond is subject to the Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT)?

Accepted Answer

While most municipal bonds fund public projects (like roads and public schools) and are fully tax-exempt, some municipalities issue "Private Activity Bonds" to fund projects that benefit private entities, such as local airports or sports stadiums. The IRS dictates that the interest from these specific private activity bonds must be included in your income calculation if you are subject to the Alternative Minimum Tax. If you pay the AMT, you must check the specific prospectus of every municipal bond to see if it is "AMT-subject" before calculating its tax-equivalent yield.

Question 6

Does the tax-equivalent yield account for capital gains taxes if I sell the bond before it matures?

Accepted Answer

No, the standard tax-equivalent yield formula only accounts for the tax-exempt status of the interest payments (the coupon yield). If you buy a municipal bond and its price goes up, and you sell it for a profit before maturity, that profit is considered a capital gain and is fully taxable at both the federal and state levels. The tax-equivalent yield formula assumes you are holding the bond to maturity and does not factor in speculative capital appreciation or depreciation.

Question 7

How does the Net Investment Income Tax (NIIT) change the calculation?

Accepted Answer

The NIIT is an additional 3.8% federal tax applied to investment income (like corporate bond interest) for high-earning individuals, but it does not apply to municipal bond interest. If your income exceeds the NIIT threshold (e.g., $250,000 for married filing jointly), you must add 3.8% to your marginal federal tax bracket before performing the calculation. For example, if you are in the 35% bracket, your effective marginal rate for the formula becomes 38.8%. This significantly increases the tax-equivalent yield, making municipal bonds highly attractive to wealthy investors subject to the NIIT.

Question 8

Can I use my effective tax rate instead of my marginal tax rate for a more "average" calculation?

Accepted Answer

Absolutely not. This is a fundamental mathematical error. Your effective tax rate is the average tax you pay on all your income, starting from the very first dollar (which is taxed at 0% or 10%). However, investment income is stacked on top of your regular salary. Therefore, every single dollar of bond interest you earn is taxed at your highest, top-tier bracket. To accurately compare how much tax you are saving by choosing a municipal bond, you must use the marginal tax rate that applies to that specific, top-tier dollar of income.

Tax-Equivalent Yield Calculator

Command Palette