Question 1

Does the savings rate math still work if my income fluctuates wildly?

Accepted Answer

Yes, the underlying math remains perfectly valid, but your calculations must shift from monthly snapshots to annualized averages. If you are a commissioned sales rep or freelancer earning $200,000 one year and $60,000 the next, calculating a monthly savings rate will give you wildly inaccurate timelines. Instead, you must calculate your rolling average savings rate over a 24-month period. If your average income is $130,000 and your average spending is $65,000, you have a 50% savings rate and remain on a 17-year timeline to financial independence.

Question 2

Should I pay off my mortgage or invest the money to increase my savings rate?

Accepted Answer

This is the most debated topic in personal finance, and it comes down to interest rate arbitrage. If your mortgage interest rate is 3%, and the stock market returns an average of 10% (7% real), every extra dollar you put into your mortgage is mathematically costing you 7% in lost compound growth. For FIRE optimization, you should invest the money to accelerate your timeline. However, if your mortgage rate is 7% or 8%, paying it off represents a guaranteed, risk-free 8% return, which is highly competitive with the stock market and permanently lowers your future living expenses.

Question 3

How do taxes in retirement affect the 4% withdrawal rule?

Accepted Answer

The 4% rule dictates gross withdrawals, meaning you must pay any applicable taxes out of that 4%. If your FI number is $1,000,000, you withdraw $40,000. If your tax bill on that withdrawal is $4,000, you only have $36,000 to spend on actual living expenses. To fix this, you must calculate your FI Number based on your gross required income, including estimated taxes. Fortunately, early retirees can heavily manipulate the tax code using Long-Term Capital Gains brackets, which currently allow individuals in the US to pay 0% in federal taxes on the first ~$44,000 (or ~$89,000 for married couples) of capital gains.

Question 4

What if the stock market crashes right after I retire?

Accepted Answer

This scenario is known as Sequence of Return Risk (SORR), and it is the primary threat to the FIRE mathematical model. If your portfolio drops by 30% in year one, withdrawing 4% of the original balance requires selling a massive number of shares at rock-bottom prices, permanently crippling your portfolio's ability to recover. Experts mitigate this by implementing a "bond tent" or holding two to three years of living expenses in cash. During a crash, you spend the cash instead of selling stocks, giving the market time to recover before you resume portfolio withdrawals.

Question 5

Does inflation destroy the shockingly simple math over long periods?

Accepted Answer

No, because the entire FIRE mathematical framework is built on "real returns," which inherently account for inflation. When the formula assumes a 5% real return, it is actually assuming the stock market grows at 8% to 10%, but strips away 3% to 4% to account for the loss of purchasing power. Furthermore, the 4% safe withdrawal rule mandates that you increase your absolute dollar withdrawal amount every year by the exact rate of inflation. As long as the stock market continues to outpace inflation over decades—as it has for the last century—the math holds up.

Question 6

Can I include my employer 401(k) match in my savings rate?

Accepted Answer

Yes, but you must do so mathematically correctly by adding the match to both your savings and your total income. If your take-home pay is $80,000, and your employer contributes $5,000 to your 401(k), your new total net income is $85,000. If you save $20,000 of your own money, your total savings is $25,000. Your true savings rate is $25,000 divided by $85,000, which equals 29.4%. Including the employer match is highly recommended because it accurately reflects the total capital compounding toward your FI Number.

Savings Rate FIRE Calculator

Command Palette