Question 1

Step 1: Calculate Gross Pay.

Accepted Answer

Because Sarah earns $85,000 annually and is paid across 26 bi-weekly periods, we divide her annual salary by 26. 
Formula: $85,000 / 26 = $3,269.23. 
Sarah's Gross Pay for this period is $3,269.23.

Question 2

Step 2: Determine Taxable Wages for FICA.

Accepted Answer

FICA taxes (Social Security and Medicare) have specific rules regarding what deductions are exempt. Health insurance premiums under a Section 125 cafeteria plan are exempt from FICA taxes. However, traditional 401(k) contributions are not exempt from FICA taxes. Therefore, to find her FICA taxable wage, we only subtract her health insurance.
Formula: $3,269.23 (Gross) - $100.00 (Health Insurance) = $3,169.23.
Sarah's FICA Taxable Wage is $3,169.23.

Question 3

Step 3: Calculate FICA Taxes.

Accepted Answer

FICA consists of Social Security (6.2%) and Medicare (1.45%). We apply these percentages to the FICA Taxable Wage calculated in Step 2.
Social Security Formula: $3,169.23 * 0.062 = $196.49.
Medicare Formula: $3,169.23 * 0.0145 = $45.95.
Total FICA Tax Withheld: $242.44.

Question 4

Step 4: Determine Taxable Wages for Federal Income Tax.

Accepted Answer

Federal income tax rules dictate that both health insurance premiums and traditional 401(k) contributions are exempt from income tax. First, we calculate her 401(k) contribution, which is 5% of her gross pay ($3,269.23 * 0.05 = $163.46). Now we subtract both pre-tax deductions from her gross pay.
Formula: $3,269.23 (Gross) - $100.00 (Health) - $163.46 (401k) = $3,005.77.
Sarah's Federal Taxable Wage is $3,005.77.

Question 5

Step 5: Calculate Federal Income Tax Withholding.

Accepted Answer

To calculate federal income tax, a payroll calculator annualizes the federal taxable wage, applies the IRS tax brackets (subtracting the standard deduction), and then divides the result back into a bi-weekly amount. Annualized taxable wage: $3,005.77 * 26 = $78,150.02. For a single filer in 2024, after applying the standard deduction ($14,600) and running the remainder ($63,550.02) through the progressive 10%, 12%, and 22% tax brackets, the annualized tax burden is approximately $9,385. To find the per-paycheck withholding, we divide by 26.
Formula: $9,385 / 26 = $360.96.
Federal Income Tax Withheld: $360.96.

Question 6

Step 6: Calculate Net Pay.

Accepted Answer

Finally, we take the original Gross Pay and subtract every deduction and tax we just calculated.
Formula: $3,269.23 (Gross) - $100.00 (Health) - $163.46 (401k) - $196.49 (Social Security) - $45.95 (Medicare) - $360.96 (Federal Income Tax) = $2,402.37.
Sarah's Net Pay is $2,402.37. The calculator has successfully converted her $3,269.23 gross earnings into her actual take-home pay.

Question 7

Alternative 1: Manual Calculation (Spreadsheets).

Accepted Answer

The most basic alternative to a dedicated payroll calculator is building a proprietary Microsoft Excel or Google Sheets workbook. The user inputs gross pay and builds formulas to multiply wages by 6.2% for Social Security, 1.45% for Medicare, and attempts to build VLOOKUP tables for federal and state tax brackets. 
Pros: It is entirely free. It offers absolute customization. 
Cons: The risk of human error is astronomical. Tax brackets, standard deductions, and SUTA rates change constantly; the user must manually research and update these variables every single year. It does not generate pay stubs, nor does it automatically file the required 941 quarterly tax forms with the IRS. It is highly discouraged for all but the smallest, single-employee micro-businesses.

Question 8

Alternative 2: Cloud-Based Payroll Software (e.g., Gusto, ADP, QuickBooks).

Accepted Answer

This is the modern standard. These platforms possess built-in, continuously updated payroll tax calculators. The employer simply enters the hours worked, and the software connects to IRS and state databases via API to calculate exact taxes, deduct the funds from the employer's bank account, pay the employee via direct deposit, and remit the taxes to the government automatically.
Pros: Near-perfect mathematical accuracy. Total automation of tax remittance and form filing. Very low time expenditure for the business owner.
Cons: Requires a monthly subscription fee. Can be rigid if a company has highly unusual, non-standard compensation structures that fall outside the software's programmed parameters.

Question 9

Alternative 3: Professional Employer Organizations (PEOs).

Accepted Answer

A PEO is an arrangement where a third-party company legally becomes the "Employer of Record" for your staff for tax purposes. You still manage the employees' daily tasks, but the PEO's federal Tax ID number is on their W-2s. 
Pros: The business owner completely offloads all payroll tax liability. If a calculation is wrong, the IRS penalizes the PEO, not the business owner. It also grants small businesses access to cheaper, large-group health insurance rates.
Cons: Extremely expensive. You lose direct control over your payroll processes and must adhere to the PEO's strict onboarding and termination protocols.

Question 10

What is the difference between FICA and Federal Income Tax?

Accepted Answer

FICA (Federal Insurance Contributions Act) is a mandatory, flat tax that funds Social Security and Medicare. Every worker pays the exact same percentage (7.65% total) on their income up to the annual limit, regardless of their family size or total wealth. Federal Income Tax is a progressive tax that funds the general operations of the US government (defense, infrastructure, etc.). The amount you pay in Federal Income Tax varies wildly based on your total annual income, your filing status, and the deductions you claim on your tax return.

Question 11

What happens if my employer under-withholds my taxes?

Accepted Answer

If your employer's payroll calculator does not withhold enough federal or state income tax throughout the year, you will be responsible for paying the massive shortfall when you file your tax return in April. Furthermore, if the underpayment is severe enough (typically if you owe more than $1,000), the IRS will assess an "underpayment penalty" and charge you interest on the missing money. It is the employee's responsibility to review their pay stubs and submit a new W-4 to their employer to increase withholding if they suspect they are underpaying.

Question 12

Do employers pay payroll taxes on 1099 independent contractors?

Accepted Answer

No. This is the defining financial distinction between an employee and a contractor. When a business pays a 1099 independent contractor, they do not calculate or withhold any FICA, federal income tax, or state income tax, nor do they pay employer matching taxes or unemployment taxes. The business simply pays the gross invoice amount. The contractor is considered self-employed and is entirely responsible for calculating and paying their own taxes (including the self-employment tax, which covers both the employee and employer halves of FICA) directly to the IRS.

Question 13

How does a traditional 401(k) contribution affect my payroll taxes?

Accepted Answer

A traditional 401(k) contribution is a pre-tax deduction specifically for income tax purposes. If you earn $5,000 a month and contribute $500 to a traditional 401(k), the payroll calculator will only calculate your federal and state income taxes on $4,500. This significantly lowers your income tax burden for that paycheck. However, 401(k) contributions do not exempt you from FICA taxes. The calculator will still charge you the 7.65% Social Security and Medicare tax on the full $5,000 gross amount.

Question 14

Why is my bonus taxed at such a high rate?

Accepted Answer

Your bonus is not actually taxed at a higher rate; it is withheld at a higher rate. Because a bonus is considered "supplemental income," the IRS requires employers to withhold a flat 22% for federal income taxes (plus FICA and state taxes), regardless of what your normal tax bracket is. The government does this to prevent workers from severely underpaying taxes on large windfalls. When you file your taxes at the end of the year, your bonus is lumped in with your regular salary. If that flat 22% withholding was too high for your actual tax bracket, the government will refund you the difference.

Question 15

What is the Social Security wage base limit and how does it work?

Accepted Answer

The Social Security wage base limit is a cap on the amount of earned income that is subject to the 6.2% Social Security tax in a given year. For 2024, that limit is $168,600. When a payroll calculator processes your paychecks, it keeps a running tally of your year-to-date gross earnings. Once your total earnings for the calendar year hit $168,600, the calculator automatically stops withholding the 6.2% Social Security tax for the remainder of the year, which results in a noticeable increase in your net take-home pay. The limit resets to zero every January 1st. (Note: Medicare tax does not have a wage base limit; you pay it on all income forever).

Payroll Tax Calculator

Command Palette