Question 1

Does my FIRE number include my primary residence?

Accepted Answer

No, your FIRE number should strictly consist of income-producing, liquid assets such as stocks, bonds, index funds, and investment real estate that generates positive cash flow. While the equity in your primary residence contributes to your overall net worth, it does not generate the monthly cash required to buy groceries, pay utilities, or fund travel. Unless you intend to sell your house, downsize, and invest the remaining cash difference into the stock market, your primary residence must be excluded from your investable asset calculation.

Question 2

How do taxes factor into the FIRE calculation?

Accepted Answer

Taxes must be treated as a standard living expense within your annual budget. If you require $80,000 of spending power to live your desired lifestyle, and your effective tax rate on capital gains and traditional IRA withdrawals is 15%, your actual required gross withdrawal is roughly $94,000. Therefore, your FI Number must be based on the $94,000 figure, not the $80,000 figure. Proper tax planning, such as utilizing long-term capital gains brackets (which currently offer a 0% tax rate up to roughly $44,000 for single filers and $89,000 for married couples), can drastically reduce this burden.

Question 3

Can I transition from Lean FIRE to Fat FIRE after retiring?

Accepted Answer

Transitioning upward on the spectrum after you have stopped working is mathematically highly unlikely unless your portfolio experiences unprecedented, sustained market growth well above historical averages. Because you are no longer contributing new capital from a salary, your portfolio is solely fighting to outpace inflation and your active withdrawals. To move from a $1 million Lean FIRE portfolio to a $5 million Fat FIRE portfolio without working would require decades of compounding untouched, which is impossible if you are actively withdrawing funds to live.

Question 4

What happens if the stock market crashes right after I retire?

Accepted Answer

This scenario is known as Sequence of Returns Risk (SRR) and is the most dangerous threat to an early retiree. If the market crashes 30% in your first year, and you sell stocks to fund your living expenses, you permanently lock in those losses and cripple your portfolio's ability to recover when the market rebounds. To survive this, experts keep 2 to 3 years of living expenses in cash or short-term bonds, allowing them to spend down safe assets during a crash without selling a single share of their depressed equity portfolio.

Question 5

How does inflation impact my FIRE number over time?

Accepted Answer

Inflation is already mathematically accounted for in both the 4% Rule and the standard 7% real return rate used during the accumulation phase. When calculating your time to FIRE, using a 7% return (instead of the historical 10% absolute return of the S&P 500) ensures that your final target number is represented in today's purchasing power. Once retired, the 4% rule dictates that you increase your withdrawal amount by the exact rate of inflation every year, meaning your lifestyle and purchasing power remain identical regardless of rising consumer prices.

Question 6

Do I need a different asset allocation for Fat FIRE compared to Lean FIRE?

Accepted Answer

Generally, the asset allocation strategy remains similar across the spectrum, relying heavily on broad-market equity index funds. However, Fat FIRE practitioners often have access to alternative investments such as private equity, hedge funds, commercial real estate syndications, and angel investing due to their status as accredited investors. While Lean FIRE portfolios are almost exclusively public stocks and bonds, a Fat FIRE portfolio of $10 million might be 60% public equities, 20% real estate, 10% private equity, and 10% cash/bonds, prioritizing wealth preservation and tax optimization alongside growth.

Lean vs Fat FIRE Calculator

Command Palette